Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Nat Winn's avatar

Really sharp article, Dave. I'm currently reading through Wallerstein's book, The Decline of American Power. Your article makes me think of his point that World War One and World War Two can be looked at as a 30 year war between the U.S. and Germany to replace Britain as world hegemon.

It makes me think further of a hypothesis posited by a close comrade based on historical analysis. That is, was the U.S., Nazi Germany, or Britain the more principle enemy of the world's people. My friend posits that it depends where you live and where you are trying to make revolution. For example was Nazi Germany more dangerous to the Indian people then Britain? I think that's highly questionable.

So while it's true that a declining superpower is dangerous and deadly, I sense that the same is true of rising power blocs for the people of the world as well.

I think when organizing in our community or in our region, it is crucial to keep this in mind and to maintain our independence and not put our hopes into other forces with whom it is highly questionable if those rising power blocs share similar strategic or political interests.

My own thinking is that it is important to drive home the message of revolutionaries maintaining their strategic and political independence again and again and I am interested to hear the thoughts of actors like yourself who I deeply respect.

Katherine Lane's avatar

Nice analyses. Very interesting and informative.

3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?